GK wrote:
A nice Rhone, balanced and peppery, as I get older and my taste matures I’m increasingly favouring sweeter / NW reds, this was too dry for me- perhaps I started on the port too young in life. However, I have no regrets at just over £4 a bottle.
Banana and wood smoke - Pretty good then. Banana translates as fruit here

Burnt caramel- interesting.
Just shows how one's palate receptors develop and evolve during one's lifetime. In the 70's except '75 and '76 Cheaper clarets were a lot more severe, and green when young and when mature, much more cigar box, balsa dry with an oak finish on the notable ones, - until the amazing 1982,
Rhones, such as the '78 were dryer and harder on the palate and the Cornas was pretty tannic. CNdP was not all genache fruit (80-90%) like it is now !
However, I did say
"
For my palate, I would not want the fruity grenache lift to subside, and spice to ascend if laying down for 2 -3 years or so" So I got something right as an explanatory TN.
This very young Fruity rhone, on my palate, the "Vitality, fresh and exciting grenache" is enjoyable as a supping wine after evening meal, nice also with some hard cheese as well. Pretty versatile actually
Glad you found it Good value. I bet you find the next bottle a bit fruitier. I say this because I've drunk 3 bottles now, and the last one was a lot fruitier in a NW sense, yet softer, with less interesting pepper and spice to my receptors.
The Co-Op 2008 CdR bargain you finished recently was less ripe ! Or was it the 2009 vintage ? And it
grew-on-you.
I'm sure (hope) other readers of Quaffers' can find, and then judge the middle road between us, and still get the general idea !
Cheers